Anal Sex Toys for Beginners

If you're new to anal play, start with a small toy designed for anal use, plenty of lubricant, and a relaxed pace. Choose a toy with a flared base or another feature that prevents it from slipping fully inside. Lubricant helps reduce friction, while taking your time gives your body a chance to adjust comfortably. These basics apply whether you're exploring anal beads, butt plugs, or prostate massagers.

There's no need to rush or aim for a particular sensation the first time. Focus on what feels comfortable, communicate with your partner if you're exploring together, and stop if you experience sharp or persistent pain. Starting slowly and paying attention to your body's responses can help make the experience more comfortable as you learn what works for you.

Size matters more than almost anything else when you're starting out. Scarleteen, a nonprofit sex-education publisher, recommends that anyone new to anal exploration stick with simple plugs under three inches and no thicker than a finger at their widest point. You can size up later once you know how your body responds.

Material affects how a toy feels and how easy it is to keep clean. Silicone has more give than firmer materials, so it tends to feel less abrasive against sensitive tissue, which is one reason it's a common first choice. Silicone, along with glass and stainless steel, is non-porous, so it can be cleaned thoroughly with warm water and a mild, fragrance-free soap before and after each use.

Lube isn't optional for anal play. The anus and rectum don't produce their own natural lubrication the way the vagina does, according to Scarleteen's lube guide, so lube is necessary for comfort, not just pleasure. A water-based or hybrid lube is the safer choice to use with toys. Interested in using silicone-based lubricant? Check your toy's care instructions first, as some silicone lubes may not be compatible with silicone toys.

Anal beads are strung together in a graduated design, with each bead a little larger than the one before it, so you decide, bead by bead, how much is comfortable and can stop adding more at any point. Scarleteen describes the right pace as "the tortoise rather than the hare," treating any discomfort as the body's way of saying to ease up rather than push through. Breathing out and gently bearing down tends to make both insertion and removal more comfortable.

Butt plugs are a single, shaped toy you insert and then leave in place rather than move in and out. Their defining safety feature is a flared base or handle, which keeps the plug anchored outside the body so it can't travel further in than intended. Beginner plugs tend to run smaller and narrower than plugs made for more experienced users, which matches the sizing guidance above.

Prostate massagers are designed to reach the prostate, a walnut-sized gland located below the bladder and in front of the rectum. Cleveland Clinic notes that stimulating the prostate can be pleasurable for some men, while also being clear that there's no evidence prostate massage provides any medical or therapeutic benefit. As with any anal toy, look for an accessory that's safe and won't get stuck in your rectum, rather than something without a clear way to retrieve it.

Feeling comfortable starts with knowing what you do and don't want to try. If you're exploring anal play with a partner, talk openly about boundaries and preferences, and check in with each other along the way. There's no right timeline or required experience level, and it's perfectly fine to take a break or decide something isn't for you.

Plenty of lubricant and a relaxed pace can make anal play more comfortable. Start slowly, give your body time to adjust, and add more lubricant as needed. You may notice some pressure or fullness, but sharp pain is a sign to stop. If something feels uncomfortable, pause rather than pushing through it. You can try again another time with more lubricant or a smaller toy, but there's no need to continue if it doesn't feel right.

Keeping toys clean is another important part of safe use. Wash them according to the manufacturer's instructions, using an appropriate cleaner or mild soap and warm water when suitable for the material. If you share a toy with a partner, clean it between uses or put on a new condom before the next person uses it. The same applies when switching from anal to vaginal use: clean the toy or change the condom first. Go Ask Alice, Columbia University's health resource offers additional guidance on cleaning and sharing sex toys.

If you experience persistent pain, bleeding, or other signs of injury, stop using the toy and consult a healthcare provider. A little patience, good hygiene, and open communication can help you explore comfortably and make informed choices.

A feeling of fullness or pressure is normal when you're trying anal play for the first time, and it often eases within the first minute or two as your body adjusts. That sensation is different from pain. Pressure can feel intense without feeling bad. Sharp, stabbing, or burning pain is a different signal entirely, and it means something is moving too fast, there isn't enough lube, or the toy is larger than what your body is ready for right now.

The useful habit is to check in with yourself honestly rather than push through either sensation to see what happens. If what you're feeling is pressure or fullness, you can usually stay with it, breathe, and let your body settle. If what you're feeling is pain, the answer is to stop and reassess, not to wait it out. Neither response is a setback. Both are just information about where your body is today, which can be different from where it was last time or where it will be next time.

Once you have a sense of where you want to start, Adam & Eve's anal sex toys category is the place to compare beginner-friendly options. Browse anal beads and butt plugs by size and material, or look at prostate toys if that's the direction that interests you.

If you'd rather work up gradually with a set designed for that purpose, the anal sex training kits category groups multiple pieces together for exactly that kind of practice, including the Pink Gem Anal Plug Set and the Booty Boot Camp Training Kit. If you'd rather start with one toy, the Gem Anal Plug is a single-plug option in the same category, and the Ass-Sation Remote Thrusting Power Plug is a plug whose name points to remote-controlled, thrusting play if you want to add that layer later.

Whichever you choose, pair it with lube made for anal play. Adam & Eve's anal sex lubes category is a good place to start, with a water-based or hybrid formula as your safe choice.

Shop Anal Sex Toys